PU vs PVC vs TPU Coating: How to Specify Water Resistance on a Bag

Most 'waterproof' bag failures are coating decisions. A plain guide to PU, PVC and TPU - what each does, where each cracks, what each costs - so the spec sheet says what you actually need.

7 min readcoatingswaterproofTPUPVC

TPU laminated waterproof fabric roll

A bag fabric without a coating absorbs water. Every polyester and nylon we sell for bag bodies is coated, and the coating - not the denier, not the fibre - decides whether the bag is shower-proof, waterproof, or a problem in January.

PU vs PVC vs TPU at a glance

PU (polyurethane)PVC (vinyl)TPU (thermoplastic PU)
Applied asThin coating on the backThick coating or double-sided tarpLaminated film
Hydrostatic head600-2,000 mmFully waterproof> 5,000 mm
SeamsSewn (leak at needle holes)Sewn or weldedWelded or sewn + taped
HandSoft, matte backStiff, glossySmooth film; matte or gloss
Cold behaviourFlexibleStiffens, cracks below 0 CFlexible to -20 C
EU retailFineOften restrictedPreferred
Relative cost+++++

PU coating: the export default

A one- to three-pass PU coating is on nearly every 600D polyester roll. It stops rain soaking through the body panel and keeps the fabric soft. It does not make a bag waterproof - water enters at seams and zips - and the industry term for it is "water-resistant". That is enough for school, business and most travel bags.

Specify the hydrostatic head: 1,000 mm is standard; 2,000 mm for outdoor daypacks.

PVC coating: cheap and waterproof but cold-fragile

PVC backing on 600D polyester is the lowest-cost waterproof panel and the classic school-bag base. PVC tarpaulin at 450-900 gsm is the courier-messenger and tool-bag fabric. Both are wipe-clean and weld easily.

The catch is temperature. The plasticiser that keeps PVC flexible stiffens below freezing and the coating cracks when flexed. PVC also softens and smells in car-boot heat above 60 C. And European retailers increasingly restrict it for chlorine and phthalate reasons - if you must use PVC in the EU, specify a phthalate-free grade with a REACH screening report.

Full details on the PVC coated fabric page.

TPU lamination: weldable, PVC-free waterproofing

TPU is a polyurethane film laminated to the base fabric. It is fully waterproof, welds for sealed seams, stays flexible at -20 C, contains no chlorine, and is recyclable. It is the specification behind every dry bag, roll-top and cooler liner sold in Europe.

It costs 2.5-4x PU-coated polyester and needs RF or hot-air welding equipment for sealed seams - which not every bag factory has. Our sister factory welds TPU dry bags and cooler liners in-house.

Full details on the TPU laminated fabric page.

Decision rules we use

  1. Warm market, cost-driven, work or school bag: PVC-backed 600D or PVC tarpaulin.
  2. Any market, everyday bag, rain not immersion: PU 1,000-2,000 mm.
  3. EU retail, cold climate, or eco claim: TPU, or PU with a C0 DWR face finish.
  4. Must be submersible: TPU with welded seams. Nothing else.

Coating weights and thickness: reading the second number

"PU coated" without a weight is half a spec. The coating pass adds measurable grams, and the count of passes changes behaviour:

Coating specAdded weightHydrostatic headTypical use
PU 1x15-25 gsm800-1,200 mmSchool bags, promo, linings
PU 2x30-45 gsm1,500-2,500 mmOutdoor daypacks, duffel bases
PU 3x + W/R45-60 gsm3,000+ mmRain-exposed programmes
Milky/pigment PU20-30 gsm1,000-1,500 mmBlocks show-through on light colours

Thickness quotes need a tolerance: we accept +/-0.05 mm on TPU film and +/-15% on PU add-on weight. A coating quoted without either number is a coating that will drift between lots.

Test it before you cut it

Every coated roll we ship passes coating adhesion and hydrostatic head on the inspection frame; TPU and PVC lots also pass a cold-flex test at the target market's winter temperature. The six-gate bag QC process at the factory then checks seams on the finished sample - because a waterproof fabric with a leaking seam is still a wet bag.

Cold-crack: the number winter markets forget to ask for

Every coating has a temperature below which flexing cracks it. The failure arrives in February, on the customs dock or the school run, months after a summer approval:

CoatingCold-crack onsetSafe specification
Standard PVC-5 to -10 CGulf, SE Asia only
Cold-resistant PVC-20 CEU autumn, North China with care
Standard PU-25 CMost EU/NA programmes
Cold-flex PU-35 CScandinavia, Canada
TPU (ether grade)-40 CAlpine, freezer logistics

We cold-condition samples at the destination market's January average and flex them 1,000 cycles before approving a winter-season lot. The test costs nothing against a container of cracked bags - specify the temperature, not just the coating name.

Compliance by market: what each coating must prove

The same roll clears or fails customs depending on where the container lands:

MarketRegulated substancesPractical effect
EUREACH SVHC list, phthalates (DEHP, DBP...)Standard PVC risky; PU/TPU routine
California (US)Prop 65 - phthalates, lead in stabilisersWarning label or reformulated PVC
Gulf (GSO)General conformity; no PVC-specific barAll three pass; heat is the real filter
JapanJIS voluntary + retailer listsRetailer chemical lists often strictest

The paperwork to request per lot: a phthalate scan (6P or 8P) for any PVC going west, a REACH SVHC declaration for the EU, and a Prop 65 statement for US retail. A mill that supplies these within a week does this routinely; one that stalls is about to learn on your order.

Welded vs sewn: how the coating decides the construction

The coating choice quietly decides how the bag can be built:

  • TPU laminates weld. RF and hot-air welding fuse panels into seamless, truly waterproof joins - no needle holes to tape. This is why dry bags and cooler liners spec TPU even where PU would survive the water test on flat fabric.
  • PVC welds too, at lower equipment cost - the reason budget tarpaulin duffels exist. The weld is honest; the cold-crack and compliance rows above are the trade.
  • PU-coated fabric sews only. Every seam is a row of needle holes; waterproof claims then depend on seam tape, which adds $0.40-0.80 per bag and a full process step. "Waterproof PU bag" without a taping line in the costing is a claim the rain will audit.

Rule of thumb from the sampling room: if the marketing copy says "submersible" or shows the bag floating, the fabric line must say TPU or PVC and the BOM must show welding - anything else is a photoshoot, not a specification.

Coating and print: what each surface accepts

The coating face decides the branding options. PU accepts screen print and heat transfer directly; sublimation only on white PU. PVC takes screen print well but heat transfer poorly (the plasticiser interferes with adhesion) - PVC bags brand with sewn labels or HF-embossed logos. TPU takes RF-welded logos and screen print with a TPU-compatible ink system; standard inks peel within weeks. Send the artwork with the fabric brief and the coating choice often makes itself.

Buyer FAQ

Which coating makes a bag actually waterproof?

A water-repellent (W/R) finish only beads light rain. True waterproofing needs a continuous film - 0.3-0.8 mm TPU laminate or heavy PVC - plus welded or taped seams, verified by a hydrostatic-head test in mm H2O.

Why do EU buyers avoid PVC?

PVC relies on phthalate plasticisers restricted under REACH, and it cracks in sub-zero handling. PU passes general use; TPU covers welded waterproof constructions without the compliance risk.

Which is better for bags, PU or PVC coating?

PU for most markets: lighter, softer, cold-flexible to -25 C and REACH-compliant. PVC for hot-climate budget lines and tarpaulin duffels where weldability and low cost matter more than winter flex or EU compliance.

Is TPU worth the extra cost?

When the bag must be truly waterproof (dry bags, roll-tops, cooler liners) or PVC-free for EU retail - yes, because TPU welds and passes REACH without phthalates. For an ordinary daypack, PU 2x delivers the water resistance at a third of the coating premium.

How do I know if a coating will crack in winter?

Ask for the cold-crack temperature and a flex test at that temperature (1,000 cycles minimum). Standard PVC fails around -10 C; standard PU holds to -25 C; ether-grade TPU to -40 C.

Free colour card and swatches

Get the colour card and three fabric proposals for your bag

Tell us the bag type and target price. We reply with two or three fabric options, swatches by courier and, if you need the bags made, a sample plan from our sister factory.